One of the most common regrets in bag purchases is getting the wrong size. Too small, and you're constantly frustrated by what won't fit. Too large, and you end up carrying unnecessary weight and bulk. Finding the right balance requires honestly assessing your needsânot what you think you should carry, but what you actually use daily.
Understanding Bag Size Measurements
Before diving into size selection, let's clarify how bag sizes are typically communicated:
Dimensions (Length Ă Height Ă Depth)
Most bags list dimensions in centimetres or inches. Length runs along the bottom, height is vertical, and depth indicates how much the bag protrudes when full. These measurements give you the best sense of actual bag size but require visualisation to interpret meaningfully.
Volume (Litres)
Volume measurements are common for outdoor and travel bags but less frequently listed for fashion-oriented crossbodies. When available, litres provide a useful standardised comparison across different bag shapes.
Descriptive Categories
Most brands use general size categoriesâsmall, medium, largeâbut these aren't standardised. A "medium" from one brand might be another brand's "large." Always check actual dimensions rather than relying on size names.
Quick Size Reference
- Micro/Mini (under 1L): Phone, cards, keys only
- Small (1-2L): Essentials plus small extras
- Medium (2-4L): Most versatile daily size
- Large (4-7L): Extended needs, light travel
- Extra Large (7L+): Approaching messenger bag territory
Assess Your Actual Carrying Needs
The key to choosing the right size is understanding what you actually carry. Gather everything you'd typically take with you and lay it out. Be honestâinclude what you actually use, not aspirational items that stay in your bag untouched for weeks.
Core Essentials (Everyone)
- Phone (note your phone's sizeâlarger phones need larger pockets)
- Wallet or cardholder
- Keys
- Tissues or handkerchief
Common Additions
- Sunglasses (with case?)
- Lip balm, hand cream, hand sanitiser
- Earbuds or headphones
- Mints or gum
- Small umbrella
- Medications
Extended Carry Items
- Water bottle
- Tablet or e-reader
- Snacks
- Light jacket or scarf
- Book or notebook
- Makeup bag
Size Categories Explained
Micro and Mini Bags (Under 1 Litre)
These tiny bags have become fashion statements in their own right. They fit a phone (maybe), cards, keys, and not much else. Perfect for occasions when you want to carry minimal itemsânights out, formal events, or quick errands where you genuinely only need the basics.
Ideal for: Evening events, minimal errands, fashion statements
Not suitable for: Full-day outings, travel, work situations
Small Bags (1-2 Litres)
Small bags handle essentials comfortably with room for a few extras. They work well for outings where you want to travel light but need more than just phone and wallet. A compact but capable choice.
Ideal for: Casual outings, shopping trips, concerts, dining out
Not suitable for: Work requiring laptop/tablet, extended travel, activities needing water bottle
Medium Bags (2-4 Litres)
The sweet spot for most people. Medium bags accommodate daily essentials plus common additionsâsunglasses, small umbrella, hand cream, perhaps a slim water bottle. They're versatile enough for most situations without becoming bulky.
Ideal for: Daily commuting, general errands, sightseeing, most work environments
Not suitable for: Carrying tablets larger than 8", long travel days requiring extra supplies
Pro Tip: The Medium Sweet Spot
When in doubt, a medium-sized bag (around 3 litres) works for 80% of situations. This size offers enough capacity for daily needs without the bulk of larger options. Start here if you're uncertain about your needs.
Large Bags (4-7 Litres)
Large crossbodies handle extended needsâtablets, full-size water bottles, light layers, books, and all your regular essentials. They're excellent for work, day trips, and situations requiring more gear. The tradeoff is increased weight when full and more noticeable bulk.
Ideal for: Work requiring tablet, day travel, hiking/outdoor activities, busy parents
Not suitable for: Formal occasions, minimalist aesthetics, times when bulk matters
Extra Large Bags (7+ Litres)
At this point, you're in messenger bag territory. These bags can handle small laptops, significant cargo, and extended needs. They're excellent for commuting professionals or anyone regularly carrying substantial gear, but they sacrifice the sleek profile of smaller crossbodies.
Body Proportion Considerations
The ideal bag size also relates to your frame:
- Petite frames: Large bags can overwhelm smaller builds. Stick to small or medium sizes unless function absolutely requires larger
- Tall frames: Can carry larger bags proportionally well. Medium and large sizes often look balanced
- Athletic builds: May prefer slightly larger sizes to accommodate broader torsos comfortably
Consider where the bag sits on your body. The bottom of the bag should fall somewhere between your hip and upper thigh for most body typesâsignificantly higher or lower can look awkward.
Common Sizing Mistakes to Avoid
Buying Too Small
The most common mistake. People overestimate their ability to pare down essentials or underestimate what they actually carry. If you're constantly struggling to fit items or leaving things behind, your bag is too small.
Buying Too Large
Large bags invite overpacking. You'll fill available space, then carry that weight everywhere. A bag that felt perfect empty becomes exhausting when packed. Consider whether you need regular access to everything in a large bag.
Ignoring Your Lifestyle
A bag perfect for office commuting may be wrong for weekend adventures. Consider your primary use caseâif you need different sizes for different situations, multiple bags might serve you better than one compromise.
The Multi-Bag Approach
Many people find that two or three crossbodies serve them better than trying to find one perfect bag:
- Small for casual: Quick errands, evenings out, minimal-carry situations
- Medium for daily: Work commute, general daily use, standard outings
- Large for extended: Travel days, outdoor activities, heavy-carry situations
This approach lets each bag excel at its intended purpose rather than forcing compromises.
Key Takeaway
The right size is the smallest bag that comfortably fits what you actually carry regularly. Don't buy for theoretical needs or unusual situationsâchoose based on your typical daily use. When genuinely uncertain, medium sizes offer the most versatility.